After the fact, I learned there’d been a prayer vigil at
the site, PSA 5, which services NYCHA (New York City Housing Authority)
buildings in a number of precincts, including the one where I live. It was round midnite when I found myself at the
site, and neighborhood mourners still straggled by – a group of friends, possibly off duty police
officers, shouted their goodbyes while a couple of – teens? Millenials? Staggered up to the makeshift memorial. Uniformed police officers hovered nearby and
in pairs up and down the block; indeed, the police presence seemed greater than usual this evening, even taking into account the fact that it was right around shift-change time.
As we approached the memorial, me behind them, the young men got quiet. They paid their respects, and were refreshingly polite when they realized I was behind them, maneuvering themselves so that I could see the memorial as well. Nestled into a triangular alcove created by the angle of the building and the
roof, the makeshift memorial had sprung up, anchored on one end by Pat Lynch
and the PBA’s huge-bordering-on-ostentatious badge-shaped floral arrangement,
and tapering off on the other side to an end-of-watch poster featuring a white
angel, the NYPD flag and shield, and murdered officer Randolph Holder’s name,
badge number, and EOW date.
I felt compelled to pay my respects there tonight. This man, whose skin happened to be black, was
murdered because he, like his father and grandfather before him, chose to wear
blue. This man was Police Officer
Randolph Holder, Jr., who was murdered by someone whose name I neither know nor care to mention, on Tuesday,
October 20, 2015.
So it was around midnight that I was there, wrestling with
my own grief and the grief of the entire city.
Earlier I’d seen Pat Lynch, the PBA president, on TV but muted it. I can barely stand to hear what is invariably his lambastic hyperbole. I found myself wanting to speak to him,
though. In my imaginary monologue, I'd say something like:
“Yes, Pat, Blue Lives Matter, just like Black Lives Matter. Can you see how we all mourn with you when
a police officer is murdered at the hands of someone whose skin is black or brown? It’s
a tragedy, and we grieve with you. When I look at the perp's face and skin, I don’t
know if he would self-identify as black, Hispanic, Caribbean, or what – I know I'd identify him as a
murderer. I can't help but wonder why it's so hard for you to grieve with civilians when a murderer, who happens to be wearing blue, takes the life of an innocent person whose skin is black or brown? If you
really believe that ALL lives matter, the grief would work both ways, wouldn’t
it? I don't see a potential bad cop every time I see someone in blue; why must you see a potential criminal every time you see someone whose skin is black or brown? There have been 101 Human Line of Duty deaths in 2015 and 25 Canine Line of Duty deaths; there have been 959 civilians killed by police in that same time period. Y'all are killing us at about 10 times the rate that your brothers are being killed. Why can't you understand the grief and outrage of civilians? We feel the same pain you do; why can't you feel our pain, too? And yes, it's still important to tell you that Black Lives Matter so you don't treat us all the way you treated James Blake. And countless, unreported others.”
But this isn’t about Pat Lynch, because I don’t believe he
possesses the intellectual nor the introspective capacity to come to anything like
that conclusion. In his mind, Blue will
always be right, and black and brown will always equate to suspicious and
unworthy of the benefit of the doubt.
Randolph Holder was murdered because of the color of his uniform,
because of his profession. That is just
as much a travesty of justice as it is to murder someone because of the color
of their skin, but Pat Lynch will only see the travesty of justice when it is
regarding those who wear the colors he wears.
So enough about Pat Lynch.
I went to the memorial around midnight, and I noticed young boys who, in
other circumstances, might likely be profiled by the police, stop to pay their
respects at the memorial to a murdered officer. I was
reminded of how Paul and Silas were in jail when around midnight there was a
great earthquake and their shackles were released.
What if the good that comes out of Officer Holder’s murder
is an earthquake of consciousness, an earthquake of understanding, an
earthquake of respect? What if, in the wake of Officer Holder’s murder, we
could be released from the shackles that bind us to our preconceived
notions which in turn keep us locked into cells of separation? What if we could all experience
freedom without having to worry about our lives being taken because of the
color of our skin or the color of our uniforms?
In the Book of Acts, after the earthquake Round Midnight,
people experienced physical freedom, and some who had been bound by the need
to control others experienced a spiritual awakening leading them a new spiritual freedom in Christ.
My prayer is that the things I saw Round Midnight tonight will lead
to a great shaking – an earthquake of sorts – that will position all God’s
people to relate to one another in love while seeking the very Face of God.
Miracles Happen Round Midnight. I’m waiting on it.
With Gratitude to the Memory of
PO Randolph Holder, Jr.
Badge#13340
EOW 10.20.15
Let's Not Let His Death Be In Vain.